Why You Can't Change Your Personality
Mark Manson breaks down why the MBTI personality test is pseudoscience and explains what the Big Five traits actually tell us about personality and change.
The gist
-
The MBTI has only 33-50% test-retest reliability and no predictive power, so Manson says to treat it like a horoscope, not a real assessment.
-
The Big Five traits, openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism, are scientifically validated and predict job performance, relationships, and mental health.
-
Personality traits are 40-60% heritable, but Manson says genes and environment interact in ways that leave individual change potential genuinely unclear.
-
Real change happens at the adaptation layer through habits, beliefs, and environment, not by trying to alter core traits, which solidify between ages 20 and 40.
Mark, Andrew and Riley agree on 7 things
See what they all use, in their own words. Paid ads are left out.
See what they all swear by Or pick your own peopleAlso mentioned
10:42
Big Five
· "The big five does predict like job performance, relationship satisfaction, mental health. There's so much..."
24:51
The Blank Slate
· "Steven Pinker has a fantastic book called The Blank Slate. It is like a 600 page book digging into all of..."
Ads in this episode
Wealthfront. They're paid, so we keep them out of the picks above.
See what Mark recommends without being paid →
◎
Related episodes
Episodes covering similar topics
More from Mark Manson
The "Everyone Is Losing" Theory
Oct 21, 2026
The Ensh*ttification of Everything
Oct 18, 2026
Why Failure Hurts More Than It Should
Oct 16, 2026
The Failure Advice That's Ruining Your Life
Oct 14, 2026
If You Want to Fix Brain Rot, Watch This Immediately
Oct 11, 2026
Failure, Solved
Oct 07, 2026