Why Keeping Your Options Open Backfires
Mark Manson explores why keeping your options open leads to anxiety and emptiness, using Kierkegaard's philosophy and modern research to argue that commitment is the real path to satisfaction.
The gist
-
Manson says the wealthiest, freest countries show the highest rates of depression and loneliness, suggesting more choice produces more despair, not happiness.
-
All meaningful pursuits follow a dip after early excitement, and infinite options let people quit at that dip and chase the next novelty instead.
-
Research on the paradox of choice shows that beyond a certain point, more options make people less satisfied and less likely to decide at all.
-
Manson argues commitment is a concrete behavioral choice, like saying no to options and prioritizing consistency, not just an idea you agree with.
What they recommend · 1 pick
This is Water
Books
"There is an essay — it's actually a speech — that I absolutely love. This is Water by David Foster Wallace. I think he describes this perfectly. He actually — this is where I ge..."
Mark, Andrew, Riley and Rich agree on 11 things
See what they all use, in their own words. Paid ads are left out.
See what they all swear by Or pick your own peopleAlso mentioned
5:26
Sickness Unto Death
· "In his book Sickness Unto Death, Kierkegaard points out that this sort of despair — this kind of despair of..."
6:46
Infinite Jest
· "Infinite Jest and a lot of his essays really dig into kind of the addictive qualities of modern stimulation..."
9:37
The Paradox of Choice
· "This is Barry Schwartz's work on the paradox of choice. He wrote the book on this, but he did a whole body..."
13:26
Either/Or
· "He talked about this in Either/Or — having spectacles with two lenses. Like for some reason, we are only..."
22:29
Bowling Alone
· "Several times mentioned Robert Putnam's Bowling Alone. That book came out in the '90s, like early '90s I..."
◎
Related episodes
Episodes covering similar topics
Therapy Culture Has Gone Too Far, Says a Stanford Psychiatrist
meaning and purpose
Jim Morrison On Being the First to Ski Down Everest's North Face
meaning and purpose
More from Mark Manson
Manipulation, Solved
Nov 04, 2026
Why “Learn From Your Mistakes” Is Bad Advice
Oct 28, 2026
How To Stop Taking Things Personally
Oct 25, 2026
Why Winning Never Feels the Way You Think It Will
Oct 23, 2026
The "Everyone Is Losing" Theory
Oct 21, 2026
The Ensh*ttification of Everything
Oct 18, 2026